YAAAAAS Queen, there is an official Broad City butt plug. It’s called the Ass Of An Angel Silicone Butt Plug. It made me say “Carpe DAYUM” like Ilana’s thought bubble on the packing!

Note: This product is no longer available. We recommend Lovense Hush instead.

Name: Broad City Ass Of An Angel Silicone Butt Plug
By: Lovehoney

Hearts: 5 Hearts
Quality: 5 Stars
Naughtiness: 4 Devils

Material: Soft silicone
Size: 5″ long by 5″ circumference


The packaging is full of Abby and Ilana, while the background of the packaging looks like white subway tile. It’s all very on brand. The soft silicone plug is black with blue, pink, and yellow stripes, It’s described as a medium-sized plug.

The Experience

It’s been about six months since anything’s gone in my ass. Anything! So looking at this medium butt plug I felt like I was staring down my demise. Okay, it wasn’t that dramatic, but it’s bigger than my others. After playing for a while with smaller toys and doing some clit stimulation, I lubed this baby up. It was surprisingly easy to get in, up to the yellow stripe.

Once I hit the yellow stripe (the widest part) I freaked out and didn’t realize I’d stopped inserting. I was sitting there with my asshole stretched the widest and thinking, “I don’t know if I can handle it getting any bigger!”

Once I figured out what was going on, I gave the plug a little push and it set right in. It was VERY secure in my ass. I walked around with it, and it didn’t fall out. I masturbated, even with a dildo pressed up against the back of my vagina, and it never came out. It didn’t hurt while it was in, but it was definitely a stretching sensation more than a presence.

It was a pleasant experience all around. Thanks, Abbi and Ilana! The Ass Of An Angel is my-butthole-approved.

Pros & Cons


  • Silicone
  • Soft
  • Cute
  • Broad City themed
  • I enjoyed the size!


  • IMO, more large than medium, so not for beginners


All in all, I have no complaints about the Ass Of An Angel Butt Plug. It was soft, smooth, easy to clean, and relatively easy to insert. The only thing that would have made it better is if it vibrated. For extra credit, use this butt plug and play the new Broad City game, available in your app store. Abbi and Ilana would be proud!

This product is no longer available. We recommend Lovense Hush instead.


If you like our site, posts, and reviews
please click our affiliate links before you purchase! 🙂
This way, a small percentage of your sale comes back to us, at no cost to you.

To ensure you don’t get rip-off or defective toys, please don’t use Amazon!

If you’ve been clicking affiliate links on other sites and want SGP to get credit,
you can clear your cookies on any browser to ensure our links work.

Note: This review is sponsored, and I received this product for free in exchange for an honest review. Some links are affiliate links, which help support the site. All opinions are 100% honest and my own. I only recommend things I would use myself! Read more about my reviews.